Edible Monterey Bay

  • Email
  • Instagram
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Pinterest


 This vibrant year-round staple tastes best in winter when its sugar content is highest

Photo courtesy Ventana Big Sur

Did you know that although carrots can be grown practically year-round in the Monterey Bay area, they are the tastiest when harvested and eaten in winter? This is because carrots, like parsnips, convert their starches to sugars when it turns cold, an adaptation that protects their cells from freezing when the temperature drops—and makes them an especially flavorful as well as beautiful seasonal vegetable for your winter menus.


Wild carrots evolved in many different colors and the ubiquitous orange color only appeared a few hundred years ago, apparently after seed breeders decided that orange carrots had the best flavor. If you talk to Ronald Donkervoort, who owns Windmill Farm in Moss Landing and sells his beautiful carrots at the local Santa Cruz farmers’ markets, he will tell you a different version of the story common in his native Netherlands—that the orange color was developed by Dutch breeders as a tribute to William of Orange, who led the movement for independence from Spain. Sources such as the World Carrot Museum, an online compendium of lore about carrots (carrotmuseum.co.uk) say historians haven’t proved this and the tale may be apocryphal, but still it persists, and it’s an interesting story, befitting its colorful subject!

Lucky for market goers, carrots of all colors of the rainbow are widely available again today. They are being bred to be the deepest and darkest of the red, orange and purple carrot color spectrum to increase their healthful components such as anthocyanins (contained in purple varieties) and beta-carotene (red and orange varieties). If you were to visit India, the Middle East or Japan, you would find varied colors of carrots are the norm because those countries never selected just orange. Seed banks and breeders in the United States now collaborate with their counterparts in these countries, hoping to bring back original carrot strains to be bred in the U.S.


One would have to live under a rock to have not heard that carrots are great for your vision, thanks to their beta-carotene. But they also reduce cholesterol and lower blood pressure due to being rich in potassium, a vasodilator that increases blood flow and circulation. Carrots also have antibacterial properties which boost the immune system, and vitamin C which stimulates the activity of white blood cells. Carrots have tons of fiber, which aids digestion and helps prevent cancer—notably lung, breast and colon.

The flavors of carrots mostly come from volatile oils called terpenoids—these can be floral, spicy, citrusy, pine like and more. If the terpenoids are too strong, the flavor will be harsh. erefore a nice balance of this compound paired with a high sugar content is what makes a carrot tasty. Imagine how many carrot flavors there are in the world. What fun it would be to try them all and what amazing dishes they would make if selected for their individual terpenoids!


Nantes carrots are thin, sweet and 6–7 inches long with blunt tips that are good for breaking through heavy clay soils and rocky ground when other carrots fork and twist. They are less likely to get woody cores when left in the fields. Nantes are favored by chefs and easiest for the home gardener to grow. A few of the best varieties are Nelson, Mokum and Yaya, which are quick to grow to a harvestable size.

Chantennay are shorter than others but have wider shoulders and are tapered with large foliage, which makes them best for mechanical harvesting. They store well, and are mostly used for processing into juice or “baby” carrots (which are actually not baby carrots at all but pieces of larger carrots that are rolled by machinery to create a small carrot). These come in red and orange varieties.

Paris Market type, aka umbelina or Tonda di Parigi, are round and stumpy, specialty orange carrots that are tasty whole next to roasted chicken and slow-roasted stews. They are great to plant if you have shallow soils as they only grow about 2 inches in length.

Kuroda carrots have good yields, are tender and sweet and make an excellent juicing carrot. Of all the tasty varieties of carrots, my all-time favorite to grow was a fat, dark-yellow kuroda called Kinbi, but I have been unable to find the seed for several years. When cooked, the Kinbi tasted a lot like sweet potato, probably due to higher starch content. I keep trying different yellow varieties but all pale in comparison to the Kinbi.


Carrots are some of the most rewarding vegetables to grow in the garden. Because they are directly seeded and like a sandy, loamy soil without rocks or hardpan, be sure to loosen the soil well before planting. In the soil make a shallow ¼-inch line with a pencil and plant by rolling the seed between your thumb and pointer finger while moving along the line, trying to plant about 30 seeds per foot. Space the lines at least 6 inches apart, or up to 18 inches in a farm row for ease of cultivation with a tractor. Gently cover the seeds, being careful not to place more soil than necessary.

Keep the seeds moist until they emerge. The closer the carrots are planted, the more slender they will be. If they are too close, they will need to be thinned out or there will not be space for a carrot to grow into one worth eating. Depending on the variety, carrots are ready to harvest in anywhere from 65–80 days. As carrot seeds age, their germination rate goes down dramatically so be sure to buy only enough seed for one season.

It is best to plant carrots only once every three years in the same location. This keeps disease pressure at a minimum and reduces nematode (tiny worms that eat the carrot) pressure and improves soil health. Since carrots are in the Apiaceae family just like dill, parsley, celery, fennel and parsnips, it is also best to not follow carrots with any other Apiaceae crop.

Onions, radishes and aromatic herbs like rosemary and sage are good companion plants for carrots as they deter pests. Tomatoes are a great vegetable to grow between carrot crops because they contain a natural insect deterrent called solanine, which kills insects that harm carrots. Carrots are also beneficial to tomatoes because the loosened soil allows more air and water to get to the roots of the tomato plant. They will need to be planted far enough apart however or the tomato will block the sun and stunt the carrots’ growth. Beans and peas are great to interplant with carrots because they add nitrogen to the soil.


Choose carrots that are firm with fresh tops that are not wilted. Once you get them home, it is best to remove the tops and store them covered in the refrigerator. Oftentimes I store them in cold water in the fridge if I am going to use them within a day or two; this keeps them extra crisp and flavorful.


Carrot Ginger Soup: Simply peel 5 pounds of large carrots and cut in big chunks. Boil them in 1½ gallons of water until you can poke a knife into them. Blend cooked carrots in a blender or in the pot using an immersion blender. Add 1 quart of homemade chicken or vegetable stock or 2 quarts of store bought. Peel and finely slice fresh ginger—about three or four knuckles’ worth—and add to pot. Roast garlic cloves and blend in, along with 2 sweet onions and salt, to taste. Cook on medium for an hour or until flavors meld.

Roasted Baby Carrots and their tops: Baby carrots (real immature carrots, not the industrially tumbled kind) are great tossed with olive oil and salt and cooked on a baking sheet at 375 F° until roasted. Be sure to leave the last 2 inches of carrot tops on as they are crunchy and delicious when cooked.

Carrot Jalapeño Slaw: Grate carrots with finely sliced red cabbage. Add tiny pieces of jalapeño and cilantro and make a dressing of plain yogurt, lime juice and salt. Top with an avocado if you have it. Great on its own or added to sandwiches.

Carrot Spread: Combine roasted carrots, tahini, fresh garlic, lemon juice, cumin, cayenne and salt in a blender. Use with flatbread or even on some pasta!


Roasted Baby Carrots with Carrot Purée, Forbidden Coconut Rice, Honey Cashews and Cilantro

Shaved Carrot and Fennel Salad with Poached Shrimp, Mizuna and Citrus with a Carrot Vinaigrette

Maple and Carrot Panna Cotta with Candied Almonds


Why would a carrot be woody, bitter and tasteless instead of sweet and tender?

These problems are due to environmental conditions while the carrot is maturing. A woody center can also mean the carrot plant was going to seed, perhaps because it was past its prime or was forced into flowering by extreme temperatures or light changes, causing it to try to procreate before dying. Carrots grow best when temperatures are between 40° and 80° F.

My carrots have swollen roots and galls on them. What would cause that?

Swollen areas on a carrot are caused by root knot nematodes, microscopic worms that restrict the nutrient uptake from the roots, causing a stunted plant. They live in the soil and can survive on many kinds of crops. Planting marigold flowers very closely for at least three months can help rid the soil of nematodes.

What if my carrots are forked?

Forked carrots occur when damage happens to the tip of a young carrot either by soil insects or various types of nematodes that eat the tip of the carrot, causing it to branch in different directions. The carrot should still be edible even if it doesn’t look normal.

What does it mean if there are round, dark holes in my carrot?

Holes in the carrot are usually from wire worm damage. They cause necrosis of the carrot tissue and look unappetizing. This happens when worms come up to the part of the soil that is moist, instead of staying lower down. It could mean there was a lot of rain, or the carrots were overwatered.

Why do my carrots have a bunch of baby root hairs coming off them?

Your carrots were not watered enough! Little roots coming off the main one always mean feeder roots were searching for water.


December, January and February


Asian Pears


Bok Choy
Broccoli Raab
Brussels Sprouts
Fava Greens
Mustard Greens
Winter Squash
Sweet Potatoes


Crab, Dungeness
Crab, Rock
Flounder, Starry
Grenadier, Pacific
Rock Cod, aka Rockfish
Sablefish, aka Black Cod
Sanddabs, Pacific
Sole, Dover, Petrale and Rex
Spot Prawns

* December only ** February only

All fish listed are rated “Best Choice” or “Good Alternative” by the Monterey Bay Aquarium’s Seafood Watch program. Click here for more information. Research assistance from Real Good Fish and Serendipity Farms.


About the author

+ posts

Jamie Collins is the owner of Serendipity Farms and has been growing organic row crops at the mouth of Carmel Valley since 2001. She distributes her produce through a CSA, u-picks and farmers’ markets.